← Back to Blog
Quick question: how much of your marketing time and energy this year went toward finding new customers versus nurturing the ones you already have?
If you’re like most small business owners, the answer is something like 90/10. Ninety percent chasing new people. Ten percent — if that — paying attention to the people who already love you.
Which is... honestly kind of backwards.
The gold mine you’re probably ignoring
Your best customers are already sold on you. They’ve already handed over their credit card, crossed their fingers, and decided you were worth it. They came back. Maybe they told a friend.
And right now, there’s a pretty good chance you’re not doing much with that.
I get it. Acquisition is exciting. New customers feel like validation. There’s a thrill to winning someone over. Nurturing existing relationships is quieter work. Less glamorous. Easier to deprioritize.
But here’s the math: studies consistently show that acquiring a new customer costs five to seven times more than keeping an existing one. And existing customers spend more, convert faster, and refer their friends at rates that no ad campaign can touch.
You have a gold mine. You’re just not digging.
How to actually identify your best customers
Here’s where most businesses get it wrong: they assume their best customers are their biggest spenders. Sometimes that’s true. Often it’s not.
Your best customers are your most enthusiastic ones.
The person who spends $500 once and never mentions you to anyone? Decent customer. The person who spends $200 but tells every person they know about you, posts about you unprompted, and sends you a thank-you note? That is a gem. Treat them like one.
Think about who in your customer base has bought more than once without you having to push. Who has referred other customers to you. Who has said something genuinely enthusiastic — a review, a comment, an email. Who shows up consistently and feels like a natural fit for what you do.
These are your people. Your ride-or-dies. And I’d bet money you haven’t called any of them lately just to say thank you.
What to actually DO with your best customers
Here’s the piece most marketing advice skips: it tells you to “nurture your loyal customers” but doesn’t tell you what that actually means. So let’s be specific.
Ask for their story, not their review. Reviews are fine. But a review is a rating — it lives on Google or Yelp and most people scroll past it. A story is something else entirely.
Reach out to your most enthusiastic customers and ask: “Can I ask you about your experience with us? I’d love to hear the story of how you found us and what’s changed since working together.” Then actually listen. What comes out of those conversations is marketing gold — the language they use, the problem they describe, the “before and after” of their experience. That’s what resonates with future customers. Not your tagline. Their words.
Make them feel like insiders. Give your best customers a peek behind the curtain. Early access to new offerings. A heads-up before you announce something publicly. A handwritten note during the holidays (yes, actual handwriting — when did you last get one of those?). You don’t have to build a formal loyalty program. You just have to make them feel seen.
Ask for referrals the right way. Most businesses either never ask for referrals or ask in the most generic way possible. “Do you know anyone who might benefit from our services?” Nobody knows how to answer that.
Try this instead: “You’ve been such a great fit for what we do. Do you have one or two friends who are also [specific description of your ideal customer]? I’d love an introduction.” Specific ask, specific person, easy yes.
Why big brands can never replicate this
(Warning...incoming Gen X pop culture reference) Remember in Dirty Dancing when Baby says she’s scared of walking out of that room and never feeling the rest of her whole life the way she feels right then? Okay, she was talking about Patrick Swayze, but the point stands — there are feelings you can only create at a certain scale, and “massive corporation” is not that scale.
Big brands spend millions trying to manufacture the feeling of community and loyalty that you can create with a phone call or a handwritten note. They have loyalty points and app notifications and email sequences that took twelve people six months to build... and they still can’t touch what you can do with genuine personal attention.
That is your unfair advantage. Don’t waste it by spending all your time chasing strangers while your best customers quietly drift toward someone who actually noticed them.
The lift only happens because they practiced. Relationships only grow because someone put in the effort. Put in the effort. Your gold mine is waiting.
Want more real talk about small business marketing strategy? The Underestimated: The Small Business Advantage Podcast is where that conversation lives. Head to shawnasuckow.com to listen and subscribe.